Superior Title is a locally owned & operated, full-service Title Insurance Company.  Superior Title of SW Florida was established in 1999 and Superior Title of Sanibel opened in 2009.  Our dedicated team of professionals has received multiple awards & accolades for productivity, professionalism and service.  We are able to assist with residential & commercial real estate transactions, refinancing, and our team is eager to exceed your expectations!

Corporate Office:

1101 Periwinkle Way, Suite 102

Sanibel, FL 33957

Phone:  (239) 579-0681

Fax:  (239) 579-0682

Renee Montgomery, Receptionist
Hospitality Specialist

Renee is the voice on the phone and the smiling face that will greet you at the door.  She is a recent implant from Illinois where she and her husband owned/operated their family business for 20 years.  As a former business owner, she recognizes the importance of professionalism and always does her utmost to ensure that our customers have a pleasant, positive experience.

Chelsea Aiello, Processor/Closer
Notary Public - State of Florida

Chelsea is a recent graduate of Florida Gulf Coast University, pursuing a masters degree in her part time.  She is detailed oriented and has excellent analytical skills which have helped her excel as a Processor/Closer.  She has already proven herself as a valuable asset and has a bright future as part of the Superior Title Services of Sanibel team.


"Professional, Knowledgeable and Superior Customer Service!"

Brenda Curran, Branch Manager
Licensed Title Agent

Brenda has over 30 years of experience in the title insurance industry and her knowledge & expertise has earned her a reputation as one of the best in the business.  After working in the corporate world for many years, Brenda took the initiative to open up her own title insurance company, Superior Title Services of SWFL, in 2003 and in 2019 merged her business with Superior Title Services of Sanibel.  Originally from Louisiana, her "down south" charm and attention to detail help ensure a warm, seamless transaction.

Amanda Curran, President
Licensed Title Agent

Amanda grew up in SW Florida and has been in the Title Insurance Industry for over 20 years.  She started working for her mother part time as a Processor and when she graduated in 1999, she joined her mother full time in Bonita Springs as an Escrow Officer.  During that time, Amanda transitioned into a management position overseeing the Bonita Springs office.  In 2009, she opened Superior Title Services of Sanibel.  Amanda's strong work ethic has helped her to become the most productive title insurance agent on Sanibel & Captiva Islands.  She is very passionate about the industry but still makes time for her family, the community, and charitable organizations.  As an active affiliate member of the Sanibel & Captiva Islands Association of Realtors, Amanda received Affiliate of the Year honors in 2015, 2017 and 2019.  Amanda takes pride in her work and strives for perfection to ensure that your real estate closing is seamless and a positive experience.  

Dustyn Corace, Vice President of Operations
Remote Online Notary

Dustyn officially joined his wife, Amanda, at Superior Title Services of Sanibel in 2020, assisting her with all facets of the business including the processing of real estate closings and refinancing.  Dustyn has introduced technology to the business by incorporating the Superior Title Mobile App, Closing Cost Estimator and certification to perform Remote Online Notarization(RON) services.  With over 20 years experience as a real estate Broker/Manager and a former President of the Sanibel & Captiva Islands Association of Realtors, Dustyn brings a new perspective to the business.    

Satellite Office:

9220 Bonita Beach Road, Suite 102

Bonita Springs, FL 34135

Phone:  (239) 390-9507

Fax:  (239) 390-9594